Hurston’s sexuality not in doubt

“When a man keeps beating me to the draw mentally, he begins to get glamorous.”


Since I’ve started my mini-Zora tribute this month, I’ve discovered a rumor that is circulating on the Internet that Zora Neale Hurston was gay. And just like the morals charge that helped to ruin her career, it’s an insidious and unfounded story that I’d hate to see grow legs.

A Google search yields all the wrong answers.  Anonymous websites such as say: “Yes, she was.” The GLBTHistoryMonth website actually claims her as one of their icons! I don’t know how they can know more than any of her biographers or other Hurston scholars. In fact, Alice Walker writes (remember her, the one who re-discovered Hurston) in Robert Hemenway’s seminal Literary Biography that the story was an invention probably borne in the mouths of her jealous, misogynistic peers and critics who were uncomfortable that Zora was “into the Blackness.”

Zora was funny, irreverent, (she was the first to call the Harlem Renaissance literati the “niggerati”), good-looking and sexy…They disliked her apparent sensuality: the way she tended to marry or not marry men, but enjoyed them anyway, while never missing a beat in her work. They hinted slyly that Zora was gay, or at least bisexual–how else could they account for her drive?–though there is not a shred of evidence that this was true. The accusation becomes humorous–and, of course, at all times irrelevant–when one considers that what she did write about was some of the most healthily rendered heterosexual loving in our literature… With her easy laughter and her Southern drawl, her belief in doing cullud dancing authentically, Zora seemed–among these genteel “New Negroes” of the Harlem Renaissance–black.


Zora seemed continually disappointed by love. It turns out she had a third husband, one whom apparently not even her friends and family knew about. Husband No. 2, Albert Price, was 25 years her junior (like Janie and Tea Cake). Her last husband was several years younger, too. Ironically, since Zora never told the truth about her age, those men probably never knew the true age gap.

None of the marriages lasted long. She was too quixotic and a wanderer, perhaps too independent, insecure or self-absorbed, to work at a relationship. It’s likely that the trauma of her father’s abandonment and neglect after her mother’s death left its scars. But her relationship pattern was to marry, then leave her husbands behind within months to pursue the next project or assignment. Things were rarely copacetic when she returned — if she returned. By my math, she lived with all three husbands less than five years total.

But she liked men and even in her 50s (her real age, not what she told the world) admitted to being on the prowl. In a letter to Carl Van Vechten, she assures him that her relationship with her roommate at the time was platonic but writes saucily about his sex habits.

No, I have not tried any of it, but it must be good, because he has mobs of girls running after him all the time. And I know Fred well enough to know that he loses no time with women unless he is getting some. I have not bothered to try it because I am going off with him, and it could cause a lot of trouble in the end. Besides there will be lots of men down there (in Honduras) too, and I am liable to run up on something that suits.

The lady knew how to turn a phrase. The latest biography, Wrapped in Rainbows, won’t get here until next week.  Valerie Boyd may have uncovered more information in the intervening years. But for now, this is my story and I’m sticking to it.


5 thoughts on “Hurston’s sexuality not in doubt

  1. If this wonderful, gifted writer , who chose not to live a life within in the the confines of other’s expection was a lover of women so what. So what?

    If was capable of holding the secret of her age and marriages who to say what else was not public knowledged.
    Please remove yourself from you moral high horse and enjoy her works.

    • Thank you, I thought I was the only one whom thought the same about this articles writer. Ms. Hurston wrote a book which had detailed explicit knowledge of same sex love; one doesnt guess this info and I can kick myself for not remembering the book & of course couldnt put my finger on it before commenting. The actress Loretta Mary Aiken, whom played Moms Mabley the stand up comedian Never looked the part on stage, but in public when she wasnt at work, had no problems being herself in a mans suit around the town of Harlem NY. James Baldwin had stayed in the closet as long as he could but revealed himself thru his writing. Ms. Hurston could not be as free, Being in the south, like many. When she reached New York City she was already closeted. Because of her, so many black women have been able to lift their heads up.

  2. I’m so glad you wrote this article! A rumor begins with someone being gay and the community grasp onto that individual like straws and won’t let go even without circumstanial evidence. Ms. Hurston lived in my county off and on for years and I know people who personally knew her. She worked as both a librarian and writer for a local black newspaper down here in Brevard County, FL. And not one of them said she was gay. But all of them said she was outspoken about her beliefs. And telling from her personal and not so personal history that if Ms. Hurston was homosexual she wouldn’t have had any qualms about voicing her opinion considering she was raked over the coals for everything else.

  3. It’s great to see someone blogging about Ms. Hurston! I’ll have to return and read more when I get some time. I just wanted to comment on this post though. Because I have some experience with autism, I have done some reading about Aspergers and found a lot of sites erroneously listing people as having it — who don’t. I’ve realized that in our society, the marginalization of people with differences unfortunately gives rise to the desperate attempt by some, to find public figures to hold up as examples of one’s own relevance as a human being. As a fellow believer in truth, I hope you can use your public platform to also acknowlege that it’s not an insult to Ms. Hurston to be thought of as gay. It just isn’t true. I think it will be easier for us all to come together as beings on this tiny planet, if we try harder to understand each other’s motives. Best of luck with your blog, and by the way, I couldn’t find an About page. Are thinking of one?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s